Controversy
involving Chief,
firefighters'
union detailed
By
Trish Cannon
Recent
troubles that have plagued the Bryant Fire Department have left
many unable to clearly understand why the firefighters’ union,
which is not officially recognized by the city, wants Fire Chief
Randy Cox terminated as chief for reasons many feel do not
warrant termination.
Over
the past few weeks, the Bryant City Council has had to consider
a number of investigations into allegations against firefighters
and Cox. A source close to the fire department stated that the
apparent allegations surfaced after firefighters Chris Spruell
and Battalion Chief Brian Watson were fired for falsifying their
time sheets on one occasion in January and again in February. An
anonymous source reported that Cox discovered that Watson filled
in hours on a time sheet when he had not worked and Spruell
failed to mark time when he did work. The source also noted the
same falsified information was found on the duty roster. Upon
noting the discrepancies, another anonymous source said that the
HR Director became involved and opened an investigation. After
it was confirmed that the firefighters had falsified their time
sheets and then tried to cover it up, the source said a meeting
was held between the City Attorney, the Mayor, the Fire Chief
and the HR Director and a unanimous decision was made to
terminate the men.
Bryant
Mayor Larry Mitchell confirmed that he did fire Spruell and
Watson based on the recommendation. The City handbook further
states that any falsification of payroll records, such as
underreporting or over reporting of working time, is prohibited
and violations of the policy will subject an employee to
disciplinary action up to and including termination.
A
few weeks later, a source with the city stated that with morale
low at the Fire Department, Cox spoke with the City Council and
asked to speak with Spruell and Watson. Later that evening, he
spoke with Bryant Mayor Larry Mitchell and the decision was made
to reinstate the men and place them on a three-day suspension.
Two sources stated that, after that, Cox took a leave of absence
for medical reasons.
During
the March 13 meeting of the Bryant City Council, firefighters
Daniel Weger and Gary Seibel spoke before the council and
announced that the local 4606 firefighters union took a vote of
no confidence and asked that the Council remove Cox from the
position of Fire Chief. During that meeting, the Council voted
to change policy to appoint the Council and the HR Director as
custodian of personnel records so that the Council could review
the allegations made in an investigation against Cox. The
personnel records that contained the allegations were then
sealed and stored in an evidence locker at the police department
until an opinion regarding the policy change could be upheld by
the Attorney General.
The
following week, after the Council had reviewed the allegations,
a press release was issued from City Hall stating that the
allegations against Cox could not be substantiated. The union
was also verbally reprimanded during the Council meeting for
leaving the City unmanned while the union members met to take
the no confidence vote.
One
of the sources close to the fire department expressed continued
confidence in Cox and stated that they believed that attempts to
have Cox fired was in retaliation for Watson and Spruell being
terminated.
Cox
stated that he could not discuss the events that led up to
Watson and Spruell being terminated or reinstated but he stated
that he learned of the no confidence vote via the newspaper. He
also confirmed that he was off for several weeks due to medical
issues and that he had been quite upset after Spruell and Watson
were originally terminated because they had been with the
department for many years and he had worked closely with both of
them.
Cox
also stated that once he learned of the allegations against him
that he cooperated with the investigation. He added that some of
the allegations against him were from events that occurred over
six years ago and that one of the allegations against him was
that he made several firefighters repair his roof. Cox recalled
that he and his men were out on a call following an electrical
storm in the vicinity of his home putting out a roof fire when
his wife called him and reported that water was pouring in
through one of the electrical outlets in their home. Cox said
his men finished up on the call and he left and headed home.
Once there, he said he was in the process of grabbing a ladder
fearing that his own home had been struck by lightening and he
was about to climb up on the roof when his crew came by to see
about his emergency situation.
Cox
stated that the men offered to help, just as they would have on
any other roof fire call made to the City, and they removed a
ladder from the truck. Cox said he and Weger went up to assess
the damage. Once on the roof, Cox stated that he was able to
determine that he had a cracked spot on his vent pipe. After he
secured it with electrical tape, he and Weger climbed down and
he and the firefighters left his wife to soak up the remaining
water in his house with towels.
As
Cox was about to return from medical leave he said he received
word that several of his men had filed additional complaints
with Alderman Rick Meyer alleging that Cox was suicidal and they
feared for their lives because Cox carried a City-issued
firearm. Allegations from Spruell stated that with, "Chief
Cox having a city-issued handgun and being known to carry it
regularly, with his self-claimed mental situation and the
majority fire department members publicly not supporting him as
fire chief any longer, I am concerned for my safety as well as
all 43 firefighters that work for the City. I personally have a
fear of going to work and the possibility of a disgruntled chief
causing harm to me and/or any of my fellow firefighters."
